LIABILITY OF THE GOVERNMENT. Administration.
Compensation for damages to a motorist for serious injuries , including the amputation of an arm, following a traffic accident . concurrency of cases in the severity of injuries. Case in which the accident was caused by a driver with careless driving, excessive speed given the circulating, but in which the severity of the injuries were due to the beam impact with metal and metal supports of the fence who were poor or improperly placed , when cutting the top and vertical poles. Therefore concur in the severity of the damage the operation of public service in a safe maintenance of the road. Fixing compensation of EUR 60,487.725 representing 25% of the amount claimed.
Responsibility government traffic accident.
The requirement of liability has its origins in the accident which took place about 17.10 hours on 7 August 2002, when appellant, driving a Suzuki motorcycle, at the height of pk 2.1 of the CN 240, Tarragona San Sebastian and the existence of traces of another accident lost control and going off the road, collided with a protective fence crawling through the beam metal. This description is based proven facts in the reports analyzed in the Judgement of the Catalan police and Unity State Highway in Tarragona.
On this basis the decision discussed in the light of Article 139 LRJyPAC, the conditions imposed by the Court to assess the accountability of government, and thus, first, a fact attributable to the Administration so is sufficient to prove that it has caused damage or injury resulting from an activity or service which shall belong to a public body; the absence of God, and cause detrimental to the organization and distinct from the accident, the latter course not detract from the responsibility of government and does impose an obligation compensation; a direct causal link between the fact and effective it is allocated to the Administration and damage, and ultimately produced unlawful damage, ie unjustified patrimonial loss.
Applying the requirements set forth the alleged trial, and based on the reports described above, the Judgement concluded that the direct cause and essentially determining the damage caused to the appellant was excessive speed the driver circulating , and the leading cause of serious injuries laying claim compensation was the clash with the cutting surface of the beam who was at the scene, being specifically attributable to the effect of the beam the destruction of muscle tissue to determine his arm amputated and subsequent injuries. Therefore, and although the immediate and direct cause of the accident was the negligent conduct of the driver, with inappropriate speed on a curved section delivered to the right, which was properly marked and in perfect condition, understands the right Judgement is that it is not of sufficient importance to be considered to constitute the sole cause of its severe impact found. Thus, as a result of motorcycle thrown the applicant after falling on the beam metal crawled on it and on the metal supports of the fence who were poor or improperly placed. If the end of the beam or fence and has filed another configuration support and had not made the feature at the top end so incised or excessive height support it have been avoided, in principle, important muscle tissue destruction and amputation of the left arm and other injuries accredited applicant.
Taking into account the determinants of the accident and contributory causes concurrent aggravated the Judgement effect fixes the quantum of compensation to 60487.725 euros.
0 comments:
Post a Comment