LEASES. Annotations on eviction for nonpayment of rent Its purpose is the resolution of a lease and possessory recovery through dispossession of the defendant. The eviction trial is stated in Articles 437 and following of the LEC and, as the Order of the AP in Barcelona on September 13, 2006, its features are:
a) is a summary, that is, with limited knowledge, it only allows the defendant to plead and prove the fact of payment or the occurrence of the enervation (art. 444.1), but not limited to the evidence used. Therefore, excluding matters relating to property, the nullity of title and, in general, the issues "complex" derived from the contents of the contract (STC 136/96 of 28 October 29 July STS 1993).
b) As this summary lacks the force of res judicata (art. 447.2). However, if indeed allows further processing, it can not be expected in a mere reproduction of eviction or renewal (including STS November 7, 1980) and should at this point to recall the Supreme Court's jurisprudence (STS June 5 STS 1987 or February 28, 1991) that attaches to the eviction, summary, at least "in part" double jeopardy because there will be certain aspects of the first process to project their effectiveness on the second, especially when there is no limitation test only facts (reasons of competition). Retains only those issues "complex" that require a prior declaration of rights.
c) Its purpose is to solve a possessory lease and recovery, through the dispossession of the defendant.
d) Based on resolutory cause: the nonpayment of "income or amounts owed by the tenant" defined and firm (art. 1555.1 Cc), however, we must stress that the standard determines the procedure does not cause the interpretation of subsequent, with whose concurrence must accept what has been prevented in Article 114.1 of TRLAU th 1964 in the contracts submitted to it established under the Temporary Provisions of the LAU, or art. 27.2.a) LAU, 1994 for contracts concluded after its entry into force.
car continues noting that while there is a limitation of the grounds of opposition (art. 444.1) as it only allows the defendant to plead and prove payment or the circumstances regarding the source of enervation, as already mentioned above, really only limited facts (the test object) capable of argument and evidence, but no usable evidence. And it allows the discussion on:
-
Payment - It opportunity to rebut, provided you entered the correct amount.
- The reality of the first enervation (exclusive of) any later
- default notice precluding the enervation
- unjustified refusal to charge, known as the default of acceptance or default of the creditor required:
-
A must overcome its achievement do need the assistance of the creditor.
-
The performance by the debtor of all conducive to the implementation of the provision (provision / provision).
-
The lack of cooperation from the creditor, without legal justification, to comply with the requirement, thereby determining a fictitious debtor's default.
-
The amount needed for the enervation.
-
The reality of a real offer of payment "owed everything" (art. 1176 Cc) rejected by the creditor.
-
And of course, the "legitimacy" can also be discussed (as they can discuss the issues affecting the title Legal and SSTS October 31, 1963, March 26, 1979, ...).
But no discussion of the amount of rent it for that matter, when they are unhappy landlord and tenant on the level of current income, p. eg. before an upgrade or increase, the framework is the regular (STS June 25, 1964 STS or December 15, 1971, among many other ..).
is why the action was negated by a valid appropriation of the latter amount as (last undisputed income), referring to the parties, if the ordinary procedure of art. 249.1.6 º for the determination of income or validity of the increase (but where the tenant has given notice of opposition, in a timely manner to increase, since otherwise there would be tacitly accepted and, therefore, compliant), however also recommended the car stated that in doubtful cases provisionally appropriated everything.
And in those cases in which the tenant intends to contest the claim, you can make the payment or deposit a precaution to ensure the minor effect of the innervation to the event that your objection is rejected.
SAP
Thus in Seville (Section 5 ª) no. 73/2007 of 14 February, in which the defendant replied, as a basis for contesting the claim, which had made the payment of income in a co-owner (they were many), the Court noted that the act of payment liberatory effects occur, it requires that the amount paid is effectively incorporated the assets of the creditor or put at your disposal, if he had refused to receive it. And since the payment is a bilateral legal transaction that requires the cooperation of the creditor, STS 24 November 1988, we need clear and strong will by the defendant to discharge its obligation, and that the implementation meets the requirements identity and integrity, ie:
- has agreed the request met and no other,
- And that means not paid the debt, but when all had been given the thing or fact which consists in providing the obligation, Article 1157 Civil Code.
Along with payment, as another course of extinction of obligations, in accordance with the provisions of Article 1156 of the Civil Code is the appropriation, which is linked to those cases in which the creditor :
-
Está ausente,
-
Se encuentra incapacitado para recibir el pago en el momento en que deba hacerse,
-
Cuando varias personas pretendan tener derecho a cobrar,
-
Se haya extraviado el titulo de la obligación,
-
Y el supuesto habitual, cuando el acreedor a quien se hiciere el ofrecimiento de pago se negare sin razón a admitirlo.
En todos estos supuestos el deudor quedará libre of responsibility through the provision of proper thing, but it frees you and determine the termination of his obligation, must necessarily conform to the provisions governing the appropriation. In this sense, the Judgement of 15 June 1987 states that "the entry with all legal requirements which entails a total release of payment, but the real deal is also positive, albeit of less legal significance, which is the of the constitution to the creditor in default, which prevents the attribution of failure who has to deliver and can not do so by the refusal of who is to receive (statement of June 5, 1944). "
is, that the city lease for his singularities, will need a receiving payment by the lessor as if the creditor, who with his uncooperative stance refuses to receive them, this would be illegitimate behavior, means that we are dealing with a case of default of the creditor, whose main effects are:
- The exclusion of the debtor's default
- and giving the lender the risk of loss thing.
But to find the existence of the delay of the creditor, the creditor must, in this case the landlord, has kept a Obstat and which has prevented the payment of rent, and, conversely, that the debtor has carried out the acts for making the payment or at least try it. That is, although certainly the creditor has no obligation to receive the benefit to which he had undertaken his debtor has, by contrast, not prevent it being released from the clamp, so that if an obstacle to this, must suffer the consequences of that "dwells in acceptance" that excludes the debtor's default.
notes, however, the SAP of Granada (Section 3) of 2 December 2000 that while it is true that there is no need eviction if the rent payment is not made in time because of the landlord, which hinders it is also true that, to bring the delay in acceptance, that the lack of cooperation in the payment by the landlord is certain , requires that the lessee, for its part, has not fallen into a voluntary delay or delay in payment of that. And is that cooperation by the landlord, as indicated, there is no sitting or establish unequivocally. Thus, if the delay in the fulfillment of obligations (Article 1100 Civil Code), integrates a breach of the obligation undertaken by the debtor to delay the implementation of the benefit due, it must be concluded saying that there is a default "solvendi."
Thus the absence, in this case, actual tender of payment, or your deposit (provision) for the case of failure to admit that he told the audience that had to exclude the harmful consequences the delay in acceptance. Highlighting further these purposes, the ten months, in which the defendant was not paying rent. Then, before it, indicates that the delay arises solvendi, which can not be expected to mask, in an alleged lack of cooperation from the creditor (lessor).
Thus, the eviction action proceeded in this case, porque declaró que cualquier referencia a la ausencia de buena fe o a la figura jurídica del Abuso del Derecho (artículo 7 del Código Civil) carece de sentido, ante la dilación voluntaria, en el pago, por parte del arrendatario y porque no cabía la enervación de la acción, pues ya se había producido aquella en un anterior Juicio de desahucio por falta de pago de la renta.
Tampoco puede entenderse lícito el hecho de que el arrendatario en base a las discrepancias que puedan existir entre las cantidades debidas, no proceda al pago o consignación de la renta, o de las cantidades que ella incluso reconoce adeudar, toda vez que se estaría usando y poseyendo la vivienda leased without payment of any consideration for it.
As to the question whether non-payment of one month's rent is sufficient to proceed with an eviction, it was noted recently by the Supreme Court, particularly in the Judgement of 19 December 2008 ( no. 1219/2008) yes. Although it is noted that in this sentence eviction thrives by being shown a repetition of default, for it was previously in another trial enervation previous eviction, stating that the payment of income verified later, does not preclude the applicability resolution of the rental agreement because under the Tenancies Act, and that although demand is based on non-payment of one month's rent and this has been paid late. And basically the reason is that the landlord is not required to support the tenant is usually delayed in the payment of regular income, because as the city lease expensive and commutative, it is clear that the first duty of the lessee is to pay the rent, too, and on the other hand, unless the parties have agreed that their payment is made at one time, this contract is successive and non-payment of one month's rent can motivate the contract termination.
Moreover, in connection with pre-emption rights of the lessee indicates the majority jurisprudential doctrine (for example, the STS of April 11, 1995) that the locus standi of retrayente, have the status of tenant of the building at the time of transmission to a third party and at the time of filing the claim of withdrawal, in any way be affected by the vicissitudes of the rental agreement, even in the event that had been instituted and were pending eviction proceedings for nonpayment of rent, as the right to retract, this is the year of the action of withdrawal, was born at the time the contract is perfected translative.
And finally, there are statements which declare that no one could argue lack of necessary joinder liability based on a possible passive standing tenant's spouse or any other person, who dwell in the house evicted, is affected by the release of housing, because the procedural law relationship is established between those who appear as landlord and tenant under contract, as demand can only be directed against those who only signed in the contract as lessee whose resolution calls for, and the fact that the tenant is not married to your partner puts it on that ground alone in a position to joint tenant / a while is living with his spouse in the house, unless he signed together with the lease, and to understand what otherwise would be to make it absolutely distorted Article 16 of the LAU of 1994 (Article 58 of the LAU, 1964) and more particularly its paragraph 1, a), which allows the spouse of the named tenant on his death subrogated to the rights and obligations of the lease, it can hardly be subrogated to the rights that have shared the common condition of joint tenant before his death, in addition to Article 1257 Civil Code provides that contracts take effect only between the parties that offer them and their heirs, and if only one of them signed the contract, being able to have done so well the other couple, only one is bound by the same agreed and signed only upon which shall be brought enforcement actions involving the breach. But there is also case law that says otherwise so good luck.