In 2003 the owners obtained a license to build a family home and not until 2006, when they receive Notification of Resolution of the City where it was agreed to initiate record urban restoration of legality in compliance with the ruling, requiring them to undertake the demolition of housing within three months and expense ... In 2003, owners and now appellants before the Constitutional Court, obtained a building permit for a house, however, the Board lodged an application Autonomous admvo. against municipal agreement granting such leave, to initiate proceedings by the Court of Ordinary contentious-administrative, who addressed the City Council sued claiming the administrative record and having that on notice to interested parties in the administrative appeal.
But although it is assumed that the City Council directed the office of giving notice, was not in it or the address to which he went, and was credited documentary the receipt, so the procedure followed between the applicant and the City Board for judgment defendant in the suit in April 2004 and agreed by both, to cancel the planning permission to build a house on undeveloped land, what led to the processing of the execution.
not until 2006, when the applicants are notified of the resolution of the City Hall where he remembered the opening of file restoration in urban legality of sentence imposed, thus requiring, for undertake the demolition of housing within three months and at their expense. That is why the appellants filed a motion for dismissal of proceedings for the acts of execution and in turn the entire administrative procedure but it inadmitió.Con Court which appealed for protection, although the implementation process while continuing and before be able to take a measure of suspension, was determined enforcement of the Judgement by the court, and proceeded to demolish the house.
Given this, the Constitutional Court noted that it was, ultimately, to examine whether it had violated the right to an effective remedy for lack of formal of the appellants, citing his repeated doctrine of "the effectiveness of the acts of location and the responsibility to ensure the proper establishment of the juridical and procedural burden on the courts, without this meaning to be using an excessive work research, prioritizing the site personnel when identifiable on the basis of data included in the procedure. " But continued that in this particular case, was not in the record established that the site be practiced or that the Court of the administrative-service defects noticed for the record and the necessary arrangements for correction (Art. 49.3.LJCA .) And that lack of formal notice to appear in the process stopped on its position and defend their interests, which need not coincide with the City which granted the license and if intervened in the appeal.
addition to not understand the Court to appear in the proceedings any information which could be inferred that the stakeholders would have an extra-knowledge of the procedure followed. Therefore concluded by noting that the breach of the applicants' right to effective judicial protection of art. 24.1 CE involves the feedback of the action at the time to proceed to the site in shape and respecting the rights violated.
STC, Second (Section 4) of March 23, 2009
0 comments:
Post a Comment