coupon only stayed a few pieces and could not be identified even if they corresponded to one or more coupons but the person "lucky" asking to be granted the right to payment of the prize EUR 30,000,000 plus statutory interest from the date you filed the administrative appeal as the Permanent Commission of the Protectorate of ONCE, confirming the decision of the Directorate General of ONCE had denied payment of the award of a coupon deteriorated. The Supreme Court ruled that the course of which it was based is that there is no coupon , and that is why the doctrine applies in the same room as expressed in the statement of July 11, 2006, which strictly assessed loss or loss of the coupon. Noting that there is no difference transcendent by the fact that a case has been lost and another damaged, because the transcendent is that in no case could present the coupon and not forgetting that in this case "even under the expert practiced can understand that it is proved the existence of the coupon, since in the test analysis of the fragments produced after washing the shirt where was the coupon, has concluded that in these fragments is established after the drawing date, the number of coupon and four of the five numbers that corresponded to the ticket, so you could even conclude the existence of the coupon, but it is not necessary, when the sentence is cited as the contrast is valuing the loss of the coupon and that is the case before the Court in which it is assumed that there is no coupon and applies, as the appellant is, the doctrine of the Chamber of the Supreme Court expressed in the statement of July 11, 2006, which strictly assess the loss or misplacement of the coupon. "
Another issue is that no one had questioned whether they wanted to collect the coupon was not collected or paid to another person, also had shown that the coupon had deteriorated and the clerk testified that they had sold stamps.
As the Supreme Court has recognized the right to the payment of the prize that corresponds as head graced with the five numbers drawn.
0 comments:
Post a Comment