is not necessary attorney's assistance to the preliminary hearing if the person attends . This becomes a reason Judgement interposition Supreme Court of Appeal extraordinary procedural violation with a single reason was based on a breach of the arts. 414 et seq. LEC and 24 EC, and mentioned in art. 469, paragraph 1, paragraphs 3 and 4, and 2 LEC. Specifically, this action marked the violation of art. LEC 414 for not having appeared at the preliminary hearing of an ordinary litigant who attended a personal, legal advice, that is, the question raised in this appeal was whether it is lawful not to have been the defendant appeared at a hearing before a regular trial, not to attend Attorney to the same, and do only the actual trial and the lawyer, since as noted the action, in this case was not required for the operation or competition, also the prosecutor.
And indeed the Supreme Court has stated that the party may attend the preliminary hearing, either personally or by attorney with power to give, admit or settle, so this decision declaring the nullity of the proceedings from the procedural point that was taken by the defendant fails to appear at the hearing before the ordinary trial followed, at which time, said the actions were replenished through application of the principle of conservation for procedural acts not affected.
himself notes that the procedural issue that arises there is broad consensus in the literature but that is not true in practice of the courts, thereby giving rise for the first time the issue before the Supreme Court , which settles the issue this way:
"The response from this room is to share the opinion that believes that if the person attends is not required (is optional) the presence of the prosecutor, for what can not be required as mandatory attendance when you do it the ; but , in any event, attend the party or the attorney, or both, is necessary legal advice. That is apparent as basic argument of the literal interpretation of art. 414 LEC, supported by the teleological elements, systematic and historical interpretation.
From the perspective of literal hermeneutics should be noted that although the wording of the provision is not the best possible, however there is no doubt interpretation can not be disconnected because the respective paragraphs 2 and 3, and considering that the alternative party or attorney with power (to resign, paving or compromise) relates only to attempt to fix or transaction, so as to other effects (remaining content, eventually, the audience) would be mandatory in all cases the assistance of Attorney. Therefore, the person or it can go through your Attorney the power legally enforceable , and the first case it is essential that the causídico also attend.
As noted above confirm the decision of systematic element, since in both the art. 414.2 LEC provides "the parties must appear at the hearing assisted by lawyers", art. LEC 432 provides that "without prejudice to the personal involvement in the interrogation that has been admitted, the parties will appear in court represented by solicitor and counsel assisted, "the teleological element in relation to the purpose or" ratio "of the preliminary hearing (art. 414.1 LEC), and the historical background, since the art. 414.1 LEC opted for the approach of the Draft (the art. 310.2 litigants said, assisted by a lawyer, speak at the hearing by himself or by attorney with power to give, admit or settle) instead of that followed the project (in which art. 416.2 provided that the parties must appear at the hearing represented by Attorney and Advocate assisted, and added in a separate paragraph to the effect of the settlement attempt or transaction, the litigants must give your attorney power to waive, acquiesce or compromise, except that, to this end, busiest and intervene personally, [and] if he does not attend in person or grant them that power, they shall not appear at hearing.) The different diction of the provisions of the Draft and spent the final text requires no further comment.
Finally it should be noted, first, that does not preclude the conclusion set out the precepts set by the judge of first instance, because art. 23 LEC refers to the appearance at trial , and does not preclude that for a non-specific procedural intervention is unavoidable attorney and arts. LEC 399 and 405 relate only to the statement of claim and defense and, secondly, that also abound in the correctness of the conclusion postulated in the resource aspects of economy, in order to streamline processes (avoiding difficulties that may arise to the attorneys to cover all hearings of their clients) and cost.
therefore incurred by the trial courts in the infringement of essential procedural rule (art. 414 LEC), having complied with satisfactorily by the aggrieved party to the complaint requirement prior to the time that there was procedural failure (obviously it was not necessary to resort to reset the order of court that had dismissed the administrative appeal brought against the resolution adopted by the Court, by adding, immediately after hearing ) and the second instance, in accordance with the requirement of paragraph 2 of art. LEC 469. Otherwise it is clear that there has been helplessness to deprive the defendant of the opportunity to practice the evidence that he had proposed and which even had admitted , which clearly violates due process and the art . 24.2 CE (right to use the relevant evidence for his defense).
Estimating the plea carries the following consequences:
-
According to Art. 476.2, last paragraph, concerning Disposal 16 th, 2, second paragraph, of the LEC, marries the Judgement under appeal, and declaring the nullity of proceedings from the "Add" the act of hearing prior to replacement action at this stage of the proceedings;
-
However, in accordance with art. 230.1 and 243.1 LEC LOPJ applies the principle of conservation of procedural acts not concerned, because under those provisions "the invalidity of an act will not involve the successive independent of that or of those whose content can not be have been different if had not been committed the offense that led to nullity. " Consequently, signaling a new trial will be for the practice of evidence that the defendant was deprived and conclusions on these (art. 431 LEC), all with great respect of the procedural principles, and particularly that of contradiction, and
-
No special assessment of costs by the authorities (subject to agreeing appropriate at the time by the respective courts) or through this extraordinary remedy (articles 394.1 and 398.2 LEC). "
Supreme Court, First Hall, Civil, Judgement of July 23, 2009
0 comments:
Post a Comment