Thursday, December 3, 2009

Fingerboards For Sale Wooden

Judgement on the Refusal to submit to a breathalyzer test

The Criminal Court no. 2 of Pamplona acquitted of a crime of refusal to submit to breath tests because the refusal to submit to a breathalyzer test is a crime only in cases of:
    • involvement in accidents or existence symptoms of intoxication
While not beyond the bounds of the administrative penalty:
    • Violations traffic (eg, going at high speed as this was the case)
    • And
    preventive controls
Antecedents:
About 07:30 hours on 26 April 2008, the defendant, of age and no criminal record, driving a motorcycle on their property at high speed. This drew the attention of a patrol of the municipal police, who proceeded to intercept and submitted to a test sample with a portable breathalyzer circumstantial evidence, which showed a rate of 0.57 milligrams of alcohol per liter of breath.

Moved to police, the defendant was required to undergo screening for alcohol intoxication by precision digital breathalyzer, warning that if they refuse would be charged with a crime against road safety. However, on a voluntary basis, successfully evaded the test, although partial results showed 0.62 and 0.60 milligrams of alcohol per liter of breath, based on which was reported administratively for driving a motor vehicle with an alcohol in breath exceeding the permitted level.

On this, the prosecution, in its final conclusions, described the act as constituting a crime of refusal to submit to the test breath of art. CP 383 pointing to the defendant as the perpetrator, not go modifying circumstances of criminal responsibility, so he applied the penalties imposed on the accused to 9 months imprisonment and 1 year and a half disqualifications from driving motor vehicles and motorcycles plus costs. While defendant's counsel requested the acquittal of the same.

The Judgement of the Court was that the refusal to submit to a breathalyzer test is a crime only in cases of accident involvement or presence of symptoms of intoxication, while not exceeding the limits of the administrative penalty in the violations traffic and preventive controls.

The court based its Judgement that "the said refusal, in circumstances that occurred, it is only because of the crowded administrative violation was not observed in the defendant firm signs of the influence of alcohol, and in fact at the hearing or the secret or the agent, speaking on the arrest, were queried about the existence of such symptoms, and, of course, (...) was not involved in any accident.

Therefore, the application stated that the doctrine was established in Judgement Supreme Court of December 9, 1999 for the interpretation of ancient art. 380 of the Penal Code in relation to art. 21 of the Rules of the road. In which, according to the same, the refusal to submit to tests for alcohol in any of the cases referred to in points a and b of art. 21 RGC (involvement in a traffic accident and presence of symptoms of intoxication) must be fastened to the offense of art. 380 (383), and that refusal in the case of the letters c and d (traffic violations and preventive controls) does not exceed the limits of the administrative penalty.

therefore be acquitted and accordance with Art. 240 LEC, officially declared legal costs.

0 comments:

Post a Comment